How to select a crystal oscillator

In the timing architecture of electronic systems, crystal oscillators serve as reference clock sources, and their performance parameters directly determine the stability and reliability of the system's timing logic. From consumer electronics to the aerospace field, different application scenarios have order-of-magnitude differences in requirements for clock signal frequency accuracy, temperature drift characteristics, and power consumption indicators. Improper selection may lead to communication bit errors, system timing disorders, or even complete system collapse. Therefore, the selection of crystal oscillators must be based on multi-dimensional parameter quantitative analysis to achieve the optimal balance between performance indicators and cost structure.

1. Quantitative Definition of Core Performance Parameters

Accurately defining the system's clock requirements is the primary step in selection, among which frequency accuracy and temperature stability constitute the core constraints.

1.1 Frequency Accuracy (Δf/f₀, ppm)

It is defined as the relative deviation between the actual output frequency and the nominal frequency, calculated by the formula:

Accuracy (ppm) = [(Actual Frequency - Nominal Frequency) / Nominal Frequency] × 10⁶

- Navigation terminals (GNSS) require ≤ ±1 ppm to ensure a 1σ positioning error ≤ 30 cm/s.

- Short-range wireless communications (e.g., ZigBee) allow ±20 ppm.

- Toy-grade RF modules can have a relaxed requirement of ±100 ppm.

1.2 Temperature Stability (ppm/℃)

It characterizes the maximum frequency drift within a specified temperature range and can be classified by compensation mechanisms:

- Uncompensated type (ordinary passive crystal oscillators): Typically ±20~±50 ppm (-20℃~+70℃).

- Temperature-compensated type (TCXO): Compensated via a thermistor network, achieving ±0.5~±5 ppm (-40℃~+85℃).

- Oven-controlled type (OCXO): Maintains the operating point through a thermostat, enabling ±0.001~±0.1 ppm (-40℃~+85℃).

Automotive electronics (-40℃~+125℃) require TCXOs with ≤ ±5 ppm, while indoor fixed equipment (e.g., set-top boxes) can use ordinary passive crystal oscillators to meet requirements.

2. Matching of Environmental Adaptability Parameters

The physical characteristics of the equipment's operating environment directly determine the reliability indicators of the crystal oscillator, and the following parameters should be focused on for evaluation:

2.1 Operating Temperature Range

- Commercial grade: 0℃~+70℃ (consumer electronic terminals).

- Industrial grade: -40℃~+85℃ (automotive ECUs, outdoor base stations).

- Military grade: -55℃~+125℃ (spacecraft, radar systems).

2.2 Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC)

- High electromagnetic interference environments (e.g., base stations, power equipment): Priority should be given to active crystal oscillators with metal can packages, which reduce radiation interference through Faraday shielding (typical radiation value ≤ -80 dBμV/m).

- Low-interference environments (e.g., Bluetooth headsets): Passive crystal oscillators with ceramic SMD packages can meet requirements while reducing packaging costs.

2.3 Mechanical Reliability

- Vibration environments (drones, rail transit): Vibration-resistant crystal oscillators should be selected, meeting the MIL-STD-883H Method 2007.4 standard (10~2000 Hz, 10g acceleration).

- Shock environments (industrial robots): Should pass the 1000g/0.5ms half-sine shock test.

3. Engineering Constraints on Power Consumption and Size

Portable devices and high-density integrated systems have strict limitations on power consumption and size, requiring quantitative evaluation:

3.1 Power Consumption Indicators

- Active crystal oscillators (XO/TCXO): Typical power consumption ranges from 10 to 100 mW (depending on output driving capability).

- Passive crystal oscillators: Only require μW-level excitation power (relying on external oscillation circuits).

- Ultra-low-power TCXOs: Suitable for IoT nodes, with standby power consumption as low as <1 mW @ 3.3V.

3.2 Package Size

- Miniaturized devices (e.g., TWS earbuds): Chip crystal oscillators of 1.6×1.2 mm and 1.2×1.0 mm should be selected.

- Industrial control boards: Common specifications are 3.2×2.5 mm and 5.0×3.2 mm, balancing stability and pad strength.

Note: Ultra-small crystal oscillators with sizes ≤ 1.0×0.8 mm have limitations in load driving capability (typically ≤ 10 pF), and buffer circuits need to be added in multi-load scenarios.

4. Electrical Characteristics and Circuit Adaptation

The electrical parameters of the crystal oscillator must match the characteristics of the system circuit to avoid impedance mismatch and oscillation failures:

4.1 Key Parameters of Active Crystal Oscillators

- Output level: LVCMOS (3.3V/2.5V), LVDS (differential output), ECL (high-frequency scenarios).

- Output impedance: 50Ω (RF systems) and 75Ω (video systems) must strictly match the characteristic impedance of the transmission line.

- Frequency pull range: VCXOs need to meet a frequency modulation range of ±50~±200 ppm (PLL systems).

4.2 Design Points for Passive Crystal Oscillators

- Load capacitance (CL): Must match the oscillation circuit (typically 6 pF, 12 pF, 20 pF); excessive deviation will cause a frequency offset > 5 ppm.

- Drive level: Usually 100~500 μW; excessive drive level will accelerate crystal aging.

4.3 Selection for Special Functions

- High-speed data transmission (10 Gbps and above): Low-noise crystal oscillators with phase noise ≤ -150 dBc/Hz @ 1 kHz should be selected.

- Remote configuration requirements: I²C/SPI programmable crystal oscillators support dynamic frequency adjustment.

5. Common Design Misunderstandings and Avoidance Solutions

5.1 Redundant Parameter Design

An automotive terminal excessively used TCXOs with ±0.1 ppm, increasing the unit cost by 40 yuan, while the actual navigation requirement could be met with ±2 ppm.

5.2 Lack of Temperature Drift Evaluation

Outdoor equipment only tested performance at room temperature and did not conduct full-temperature range frequency sweeping (-40℃~+85℃), resulting in batch temperature drift exceeding standards.

5.3 Insufficient Reliability Verification

Failed to pass 1000-hour high-temperature aging (+125℃) and temperature cycle tests (-55℃~+125℃, 1000 cycles), leading to batch failures in the later stage.

Verification Standard: After selection, a 1000-hour high-temperature and high-humidity (85℃/85% RH) powered operation test must be conducted to ensure that the frequency drift is ≤ 1.5 times the initial value.

The selection of crystal oscillators is a core part of system timing design. It is necessary to adopt a four-step principle of "quantification of performance indicators → matching of environmental parameters → adaptation of electrical characteristics → balance of cost and risk" to achieve the unity of technical feasibility and commercial rationality. The final selection result must undergo long-term verification under actual operating conditions to ensure stable clock output throughout the entire life cycle, providing a solid timing foundation for the reliable operation of electronic systems.

About Mandu Technology

Shenzhen Mandu Technology Co., Ltd. has steadfastly centered its operations on the distribution of high-performance, high-quality, and highly reliable integrated circuit products. Its portfolio encompasses memory chips, differential crystal oscillators, and MCU microcontrollers, while progressively integrating analog signal chain products. The company prides itself on delivering comprehensive and cost-effective solutions to its customers. Its products find applications across a broad spectrum of industries, including but not limited to network communication, industrial control, robotics, medical equipment, personal health, and numerous other fields.

Business: sales@manduic.com

Website: www.manduic.com

Sales: +86 150-1290-5940